Setting up an aquarium can be a great experience, but probably the single largest question facing every new fish enthusiast is saltwater or freshwater. Each has its advantages, challenges, and beauty, and what you chose will affect everything from the fish you own to the level of maintenance required.
Freshwater Aquariums: Most of the time, setting up an aquarium can be quite affordable. Freshwater tanks have simpler setups in that regard and don’t require expensive lighting, advanced filtration, or elaborate testing kits. You can often get a freshwater setup for a few hundred dollars, depending on the tank size and type of fish you will be keeping
Saltwater aquariums: Saltwater tanks are always more costly. Besides the tank itself, you’ll have to get special equipment for it, such as a protein skimmer, live rock for biological filtration, and possibly a sump system. You will also need to buy salt mixes on a regular basis.
Winner: Freshwater tanks are easier on the wallet both at the initial stage and throughout their running lives.
Freshwater Fish: There is such a variety of freshwater fish, colorful and very lively, ranging from guppies and tetras to angelfish and bettas. Freshwater tanks provide good varieties when it comes to plant life, creating a natural setting. While most freshwater fish are hardy, they are also relatively inexpensive, which means one can experiment with a variety of species without breaking into the bank.
Saltwater: Saltwater tanks open the door to stunning, colorful species one simply would not find in freshwater, such as clownfish, tangs, and even small sharks. It is out of this world, but that beauty costs a bit more per fish. Saltwater fish are generally much more sensitive to the conditions of the water; therefore, they need to be taken care of with much caution and under stable environments to see them thrive.
Winner: For pure vibrancy and species offered, the saltwater tanks take the cake; however, at lower costs, more variety can be attained with freshwater tanks.
Freshwater: Freshwater tanks are easier to maintain due in large part to the hardiness of both the fish and plants. This will generally consists of a weekly water change, filter cleanings from time to time, and testing of pH and ammonia. For the most part, many freshwater species can tolerate minor fluctuations in water quality, which makes this a good option for beginners.
Saltwater: On the other hand, saltwater tanks demand more maintenance and accuracy. You will need to test more parameters, such as salinity, calcium, and alkalinity, in order for stability within the marine environment to be maintained. Even slight fluctuations in water chemistry will be damaging to your fish. Saltwater tanks may need weekly maintenance and equipment – such as protein skimmers-often require regular attention, too.
Winner: Freshwater is the obvious winner for simplicity and ease of maintenance, particularly for the newcomer to aquarium care.
Freshwater: Freshwater tanks have a more classic, natural presentation. Aquascaping, when it involves freshwater, can be very organic-looking as it most often features live plants, rocks, and driftwood. Live plants are stunningly attractive; they also help to purify water with their ability to absorb nitrates.
Saltwater: Saltwater tanks have a lot more life inside of them due to their generally being more colorful. The coral reefs, the living rock, and the sand beds create a huge visual underwater landscape. Many saltwater tank owners utilize a “reef” setup that incorporates corals, which are beautiful in color and shape but do require higher lighting and more careful water maintenance.
Winner: This is a toss-up. Freshwater tanks are perfect if you want to have that natural vibe, with the right look and feel for you. Saltwater tanks shine in their coral displays, which are alive with color and intricate detail.
Freshwater: Most freshwater fish are farmed, making their ecological impact generally quite low. The big difference lies in the ready availability of sustainable species selection, which makes setting up an environmentally friendly freshwater aquarium much easier.
Saltwater: The majority of saltwater fish are usually harvested from the wild; the reefs and oceanic ecosystems take a beating from it. Large numbers of today’s aquarist, however look for sustainable- or tank-reared marine species. Your options include identifying tank-bred fish and synthetic live rocks as opposed to the harvesting of natural coral to reduce the environmental impact of your setup in saltwater.
Winner: Generally speaking, freshwater aquariums are less impactful on the environment; even more so when they are stocked with fish that have been farmed sustainably.
| Feature | Freshwater Tank | Saltwater Tank |
|---|---|---|
|
Cost |
Less expensive to establish and maintain |
More expensive to start up and to maintain |
|
Fish Variety |
Many species, hardier species |
Colorful, exotic, but sensitive |
|
Maintenance |
Less maintenance, fewer water tests |
Highly maintained, requires precision |
|
Decor/Aesthetic |
Natural look with plants and rocks |
Vibrant reefs, living rock, corals |
|
Environmental Impact |
Less, farmed fish widely available |
Higher, but tank-bred options exist |
Freshwater: Those who have just started, want an easy setup, or do not have much time for maintenance may set up a freshwater tank. The budget for freshwater fish and plants is quite reasonable, eco-friendly, and does not lack variety to enjoy.
Saltwater: In case you are already a seasoned aquarist, fond of a challenge, and willing to invest in a poppy-looking and dynamic tank, then saltwater fish may be exactly what you need. While saltwater aquariums are more expensive and require much more maintenance, what-ever oath it may be, they pay off atleast for the most ambitious of dedicated people.
In the end, it all depends on your budget, how much time you are willing to put into it, and what you want from your aquarium experience. Both can bring into your home a lovely bit of life in the water that is so relaxing, yet riveting, and forever rewarding.
Sign up for our newsletter and receive the next story before it is lunched
Our blog is made with love to give you advice on how to take care of your beloved pets and to help you learn everything about their stories
